I am a little late to Trinity Western University v The Law Society of Upper Canada, 2015 ONSC 4250, the second in what is likely to become a lengthy string of judicial decisions on whether TWU’s law school should be accredited by Canada’s law societies. The first decision, favourable to TWU, came from Nova Scotia […] Read more

Where I come from we sometimes joke that rugby is a game played by gentlemen with odd-shaped balls. The same is true of the human demolition derby — American football — so popular in my current location. And even those of us who tune in to the Superbowl only for the ads know that star […] Read more

(This is the third in a series of posts. Read the first and second. The draft can be downloaded in its entirety here.) Sometimes, in order to take the necessary much closer look, it is necessary to carefully peel off the labels applied to particular ‘forms’ of administrative decision-making. These labels are conclusory, functioning as […] Read more

Now that all the fuss about his past life as a blogger has died down, it is safe to venture a few comments about Justice Russell Brown’s appointment to the Supreme Court. He replaces Rothstein J., who retires today, leaving a very large gap in the Court’s administrative law and economic regulation expertise. Brown J. […] Read more

(For the first post in this series, see here). The draft can be downloaded in its entirety here. Perhaps the most attractive – though also the most facile – endeavour for those who think deeply about administrative law is to formulate a general principle that unifies disparate strands of case-law. This then functions as a […] Read more

Readers may be interested in Cheryl Saunders, “The Concept of the Crown“: This article deals with the weight that is borne by the concept of the Crown in the public law of common law jurisdictions in the absence of a developed theory of the state. I argue that the concept of the Crown has evolved […] Read more

In late October, I will be presenting a paper at a conference organized by the Canadian Bar Association in honour of former Supreme Court of Canada Justice Louis LeBel. I have spent the last couple of weeks working on a draft and will share it with readers in a series of posts. In this post, […] Read more

I posted about the first-instance decision in Canadian Arab Federation v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2015 FCA 168 a while ago. Here, the Minister refused to enter into a new agreement with the Federation because of what he perceived as anti-semitic comments by one of its representatives. My particular interest is in the procedural fairness […] Read more

Naraine v. Canada (Attorney General), 2015 FC 934 recently provoked the breathless — and breathtakingly misleading — headline: “Prison can’t take porn channels away from inmates, federal court rules“. The trigger for the Naraine litigation was apparently a parliamentary hearing on sexual harassment in the federal workplace before the Standing Committee on the Status of […] Read more

As has often been said by administrative lawyers waiting at bus-stops, you wait ages for a major case on the exercise of ministerial powers by subordinates and then two come along at once. There is an excellent review of the general principles in MacMenamin J.’s judgment for the Irish Supreme Court in W.T. v. Minister […] Read more