Comments | Page 71
Comments
Covering the Bases: Miller and the European Union (Notification of Withdrawal) Bill
Paul Daly January 27, 2017
Readers will be interested to note that the bill that responds to the UK Supreme Court’s judgment in Miller has now been published. The European Union (Notification of Withdrawal) Bill contains one substantive section, which provides: (1) The Prime Minister may notify, under Article 50(2) of the Treaty on European Union, the United Kingdom’s intention […] Read more
Comments
The Form of the Article 50 Authorisation Bill: Some Early Thoughts on Miller [2017] UKSC 5
Paul Daly January 24, 2017
From the UK Supreme Court’s decision this morning in Miller it is quite clear that legislation is required to authorise the triggering of Article 50. But what form should such legislation take? The majority decision does not give much explicit guidance. At para. 86, we are told that there must be “domestic sanction” in “appropriate […] Read more
Comments
Brexit: Some International Law Aspects
Paul Daly January 23, 2017
In a week that is likely to be dominated by the public law implications of Brexit — the UK Supreme Court will hand down its much-anticipated decision in the Article 50 litigation tomorrow — I thought it would be timely to draw your attention to some related international law issues. Brexit, and more particularly Scotexit, […] Read more
Comments
How (Not to) Quash Inadequately Reasoned Decisions: Taman v. Canada (Attorney General), 2017 FCA 1
Paul Daly January 12, 2017
When Emilie Taman sought to run for office in the last Canadian general election, she was refused permission to do so by the Public Service Commission. That refusal has now been set aside: Taman v. Canada (Attorney General), 2017 FCA 1. However, as I will explain, it has been set aside in a way which […] Read more
Comments
Legislating for and Regulating In Emergencies: New Zealand’s Regulations Review Committee
Paul Daly January 9, 2017
A topic to which I had not given a great deal of thought before I taught it last Term as part of an LLM seminar on “Legislation” is the form of emergency legislation. As someone who lived through the 2000s and spent time in U.S. universities whilst the executive branch claimed significant authority to act […] Read more
Comments
Harold Laski on Experts and Expertise
Paul Daly January 6, 2017
When I was a doctoral student, I spent months trying to track down an essay by Harold Laski: ‘The Limitations of the Expert’ (1931) 162 Harper’s Monthly Magazine 101 (Fabian Tract No. 235). I eventually found it in a rare books collection at Harvard University while I was there as a visiting researcher. Finally finding […] Read more
Comments
Groves and Weeks eds, Legitimate Expectations in the Common Law World
Paul Daly January 4, 2017
I recently received my complimentary copy of a new edited collection, Matthew Groves and Greg Weeks eds., Legitimate Expectations in the Common Law World (Hart Publishing, Oxford, 2017). The title is available for pre-order here. The editors write: The recognition and enforcement of legitimate expectations by courts has been a striking feature of English law […] Read more
Comments
Responses to Maladministration, à la française: la Cour de justice and Christine Lagarde
Paul Daly December 28, 2016
Francophile readers of this blog will no doubt enjoy JP blog, a new blawg operating under the auspices of Jus Politicum. Those of you, Francophile or otherwise, who are interested in official responses to maladministration will find a great deal of interest in two recent posts by Professor Olivier Beaud on the recent decision of […] Read more
Comments
Datafin Redux: Administrative Law Values and the Boundaries of Judicial Review
Paul Daly December 23, 2016
In area of judicial control of non-statutory powers, the “boundaries” of judicial review are “uncertain” (Wade & Forsyth, Administrative Law, 11th ed. (Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2014), at p. 532. There have been various efforts to shed light on them over the years. Particularly useful illumination can be provided by the underlying purposes and values […] Read more
Comments
Modes of Rights Protection IV: A Public Law Model
Paul Daly December 22, 2016
Here is the final installment of my posts on rights protection in administrative law: you can also read posts one, two and three. My proposed “public law model” would draw on the strengths of administrative law and constitutional law. Abella J. was quite right to set out in Doré to try and draw on the […] Read more